I may or may not be obsessed with Crumbl Cookie right now. Here's a list of how good each cookie is. Chocolate Chip is rated at 10/10, so you'll just have to recalibrate lmfao.
I'm a frosting hater generally, but the Crumbl frosting is generally amazing!! On basically every other dessert (except maybe chinese cakes), I'll brush off most of the frostong, but I eat the crumbl frosting without modification.
S'mores Cookie - 13/10 my favorite in July 2025. I was devastated when I realized that each flavor is only available for a week
Chocolate Cake Batter Cookie - 11/10 Love it. Eating this cookie, I understand why my husband is so obsessed with Chocolate Cake with Chocolate frosting. I've only ever had this combo from the grocery store, and it is WAY diff.
Chocolate Chip - 10/10 the classic, can't go wrong. Could use 30 seconds longer in the oven but, ya know,.
Red Velvet Cupcake Cookie - 10/10 really good.
Peanut Butter Cup Skillet Cookie - 10/10 also a tossup w/ chocolate chip. Depends on what I'm feeling that day.
Caramel Shortbread Cookie ft. Twix - 8/10, best of their chilled cookies thus far, but I don't know that I'd order it again unless I had no other ideas.
Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie - 7/10, great flavor wise but chilled cookies are ~~ eh.
Pink Velvet Cake Cookie - 5/10 kind of non-descript
Cookies and cream milkshake cookie - 5/10, chilled cookies are again, kinda ehh.
Blue Raspberry Cookie - 3/10 - I'm a blue raspberry girlie and had to try this cookie, but it was honestly just kind of bad chilled. I let it get to room temperature and it became slightly better, but I wouldn't order it again.